Tue 31 Jan 2012, 13:54 GMT

Regulating ships in Hong Kong - progress and incentives


Think tank calls on Hong Kong to 'seize the opportunity' and regulate quickly.



Regulating ships in Hong Kong - progress and incentives
By Veronica Booth [pictured], Civic Exchange

The Hong Kong Environmental Protection Department (EPD) recently presented proposals to reduce emissions from vessels to improve air quality in Hong Kong at an Environmental Affairs Panel meeting in Hong Kong’s Legislative Council in December 2011. This is a positive step towards regulation in Hong Kong and the Pearl River Delta (PRD) region more generally.

These proposals include regulation for ocean-going vessels (OGVs, like container ships and cruise ships) while they are at berth in Hong Kong; regional regulation across the PRD through exploring an "Emission Control Area"; and using cleaner fuel for smaller vessels such as barges, tug boats and ferries.

Improving Hong Kong's air quality is a pressing issue, and on the Hong Kong public's mind, given recent news that Hong Kong's nitrogen dioxide levels are the worst they have ever been. Air quality improvements need to start happening now, and quickly.

Timing is a particular concern for leading shipping lines in Hong Kong participating in the Fair Winds Charter, the world’s first and only shipping industry-led, voluntary, at-berth, unsubsidized fuel switch, which is halfway through its 2 year run. An industry association estimated that, to switch the most container vessels to a cleaner fuel would cost USD50 million annually to switch most container vessels calling at Hong Kong.

The EPD has indicated that since the Charter began in January 2011, emissions have dropped from OGVs. EPD is clearly moving towards proposing regulation. But regulation takes time to come into effect. So the question becomes, how do we maintain the gains made from this ambitious initiative between the Charter’s end, and when regulation comes into force?

One way may be to incentivize shipping lines to continue to switch until that time. This could have the added bonus of attracting shipping lines that haven’t joined the Charter to operate at a higher standard more quickly.

The World Port Climate Initiative administers the Environmental Ship Index, (ESI), which covers NOx, SOx and CO2 and is designed to improve the environmental performance of ships. It gives points for ships performing beyond current regulation. The ESI scale runs from 0 to 100, with 0 being ships that comply with current regulation, and ships that perform better than current regulation score points.

The ESI gives emissions at port a heavier weighting to reflect the public health impact they have while close to people. Several ports have been using the ESI to offer subsidies to shipping lines that exceed regulation. The Port of Antwerp is using the ESI to identify ships eligible for a 10 percent discount on tonnage dues with an ESI rating of over 31. Similarly, Hamburg and Rotterdam give a discount of up to 10 percent for ships with an ESI rating over 20.

Other ports have adopted other criteria to incentives ships to be cleaner. Port Metro Vancouver’s EcoAction Program is a three-tiered award and subsidy scheme to encourage ships to switch to cleaner fuel. The ports of Los Angeles and Long Beach similarly had recognition and incentives to switch to cleaner fuel, before the current tighter regulation came into place. This program required vessels to slow down to 12 knots while approaching the ports, and switch their auxiliary engines to a distillate fuel while at berth. The financial incentive covered the cost difference between the bunker fuel and distillate fuel used.

Singapore is the only port in Asia incentivizing vessels to exceed regulations by reducing emissions. Until 2015, ships are eligible for a 15 percent reduction in port dues if they reduce emissions by using a fuel with a sulphur content of 1 percent or less (the global standard is 3.5 percent), or an abatement technology such as a scrubber, which would reduce SO2 emissions by an equivalent amount.

So options abound for the Hong Kong government to maintain the good work started by the shipping industry. The task is now to seize the opportunity during this time of transition, and to regulate quickly.

Image: Veronica Booth - Senior Project Manager at Hong Kong-based public policy think tank Civic Exchange. She has been the principal investigator and stakeholder convenor for the "Green Harbours Community" since it was formed in 2008.


Molslinjen vessel render. AYK Energy secures battery contract for Molslinjen's electric fast ferries  

Battery maker to supply 165MWh for three electric catamarans after cutting system weight by nearly half.

Giosue Vezzuto, RINA. Giosuè Vezzuto named CEO of RINA Services, taking charge of marine and certification arm  

Naval engineer with nearly three decades at RINA succeeds Paolo Moretti to lead the group's marine and certification division.

Acta Aquarius vessel. Acta Marine completes four-vessel newbuild programme with delivery of methanol dual-fuel Acta Aquarius  

Dutch offshore support vessel operator takes delivery of its fourth Tersan-built CSOV, featuring dual-fuel methanol propulsion.

Wind-assisted vessel illustration. Lloyd's Register backs GCMD methodology for verifying wind propulsion fuel savings  

Independent review aims to boost confidence in wind-assisted propulsion performance and unlock sustainable finance for energy-efficiency retrofits.

CM Wuhan vessel. China Merchants delivers first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by CCS  

The 7,800-CEU CM Wuhan is the first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by China Classification Society.

Andre M ammonia-fuelled gas carrier. China delivers first domestically built ammonia-fuelled gas carrier  

CCS-classed vessel becomes the world's second ammonia-fuelled gas carrier, testing rules for the IMO's zero-carbon shipping transition.

Nordion Energi liquefied biogas (LBG) facility render. Storage tank installed as Gothenburg's LBG bunkering plant advances towards 2027 completion  

Nordion Energi's liquefied biogas facility at the Port of Gothenburg takes a step forward with tank installation.

Maran Myron vessel. Maran Tankers takes delivery of dual-fuel Suezmax Maran Myron  

Vessel is sixth dual-fuel tanker in eight-vessel series built by New Times Shipbuilding.

Lake Victoria truck-to-ship (TTS) bunkering operation. EPS completes first truck-to-ship LNG bunkering operation in Davisville  

Fuel delivered to the pure car and truck carrier Lake Victoria whilst at berth.

Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore logo. MPA opens applications for LNG floating storage unit licences  

Singapore invites applications for up to two LNG floating storage unit licences to bolster bunkering supply resilience.