Mon 24 Nov 2014, 00:01 GMT

Carnegie scrutinized in Sweden over OW Bunker bankruptcy


Investment bank is 'asked questions' by Sweden's Financial Supervisory Authority about the collapse of Danish bunker firm.



Stockholm-headquartered financial services group, Carnegie Investment Bank AB, finds itself embroiled in the aftermath of the collapse of OW Bunker as more questions are asked about who was responsible for one of the world's leading marine fuels companies to go bust.

When OW Bunker's initial public offering (IPO) prospectus was unveiled on March 18, 2014, the joint global coordinators were named as Carnegie and the American financial services corporation, Morgan Stanley. The joint bookrunners were Carnegie, Morgan Stanley and Nordea Bank AB (Nordea) - another financial services group headquartered in Stockholm - and the co-lead manager was ABG Sundial Collier, an Oslo-based investment bank.

The 291-page prospectus included a number of comments regarding the mitigation of risk, such as "In accordance with our conservative operating philosophy and corporate culture, we reduce or mitigate our marine fuel price risk and credit risk through hedging and insurance and we provide value to our customers and suppliers by being able to leverage our global scale and advanced product offering enabled by our centralised and integrated platform."

The document also said: "As part of our integrated approach, our established risk management function controls and manages risks across our integrated business model. This has supported the successful growth of our business and creation of a diversified customer base. Our business has proven resilient to changes in macroeconomic conditions, oil and marine fuel prices and shipping rates."

On March 28, shares of OW Bunker were traded on the Nasdaq OMX Copenhagen stock exchange for the first time. The share price closed on the first day of trading at 175 Danish kroner and went on to reach a peak of 186 Danish kroner per share before plummeting to 83.50 per share on November 5, when trading of the company's shares was suspended.

With shares of OW Bunker now worthless, approximately 20,000 private shareholders are esimated to have lost money as a result of the collapse, which also left several hundred people unemployed.

One issue that raised eybrows was how Carnegie, owned by Altor Equity Partners, was allowed to be responsible for compiling the IPO prospectus of another Altor-owned business, OW Bunker.

The situation was not helped either by Carnegie recommending its clients to buy stock in OW Bunker at 220 Swedish kronor (176 Danish kroner) in May.

Last week's comments by former risk manager, Kenneth Rosenmeyer, who is quoted as saying that the $27 million he made in 2013 was from 'pure speculation', has also led to questions about how the IPO prospectus was compiled and the role of OW Bunker's senior management, the board of directors, Altor and the two prospectus coordinators.

"If there is an indictment on prospectus liability, I'm pretty sure that the two investment banks will be held accountable. Carnegie and Morgan Stanley may have a claim for damages of hundreds of millions of kroner," Jens Møller Nielsen, CEO of the Danish Shareholders' Association told Svenska Dagbladet.

The Danish organization is said to have over 5,800 small shareholders who are prepared to take legal action against those responsible for the bankruptcy. More than 300 million Danish kroner is being claimed in damages, according to Nielsen.

Sweden's Financial Supervisory Authority (FSA), Finansinspektionen, also appears to be following events closely. The regulator confirms that it has already been in contact with the management of Carnegie.

"We are of course aware of the situation for some time and have also been in contact with the bank and asked questions about the incident. Exactly what the questions were, we cannot comment. But fundamental to all financial supervision, banks should be able to count on operational risks and set aside money to cover them," Jonathan Holst, Head of the FSA, told Svenska Dagbladet.

When asked about events, Rickard Buch, press officer at Carnegie, told Svenska Dagbladet: "It is deeply tragic, what has happened. But we have no reason to speculate on the development of events. We have just now as little information as everyone else."

In answer to a question regarding whether Carnegie fears a claim from shareholders, Buch said: "No, we are confident about the processes and the people we have in the IPOs we are involved in. Carnegie has done more IPOs than any other in the Nordic market and we know what we are doing. But in this dramatic case, we fully understand the anger that shareholders may feel."


Castrol Logo. Castrol teams up with Stone Oil to expand marine lubricant supply on US Gulf Coast  

Partnership gives Gulf Coast vessel operators direct access to Castrol Seamax lubricants through Stone Oil's distribution network.

Keel-laying ceremony for Natalia Cosulich. Keel laid for Natalia Cosulich, final vessel in Cosulich's methanol-ready tanker series  

Fratelli Cosulich Marine Energy marks construction milestone for the fourth bunker tanker in its fleet expansion programme.

Titan Clean Fuels logo. Titan Clean Fuels seeks commercial manager to grow LNG bunkering business  

Amsterdam-based LNG bunker supplier advertises role to expand marine fuel sales and manage vessel scheduling.

Reception area at Monjasa's Singapore office. Monjasa seeks supply trader to join Singapore operation  

Experience in Singapore's bunker supply industry required; fluency in Mandarin an advantage.

Shipping industry associations' MEPC joint statement logos. Shipping groups urge IMO to agree global GHG framework ahead of MEPC 85  

Nine industry bodies representing the global commercial fleet call for a single, enforceable set of decarbonisation rules rather than fragmented national or regional measures.

Launching ceremony for MSC Rafaela. Changhong International launches LNG dual-fuel boxship for MSC  

19,000-TEU vessel said to be the largest LNG dual-fuel container ship built in Zhejiang province to date.

Izanami naming ceremony. World's first vessel with ammonia-fuelled main and auxiliary engines unveiled  

Medium gas carrier Izanami unveiled ahead of time-charter trials.

Glovis Noble naming ceremony. SWS names dual-fuel car carrier for Korea Ocean Business Corporation  

Shanghai Waigaoqiao Shipbuilding names 10,800-CEU Glovis Noble in ceremony.

Petrobras logo. Petrobras boosts Santos bunker capacity after pier upgrade, eyes year-end sales push  

Supplier says barge pier works completed in early November have lifted daily bunker delivery capacity as it targets growth.

Island Explorer vessel render. Consortium wins funding to develop nuclear propulsion system for offshore vessels  

MarNuPS is centred on building and testing a shipboard nuclear reactor system by 2031–32.