Mon 25 Aug 2014, 11:31 GMT

Study compares natural gas and conventional marine fuel emissions


111-page report was prepared by the University of Delaware and The Rochester Institute of Technology.



The US Department of Transportation's Maritime Administration (MARAD) recently released a study that evaluates total fuel cycle emissions for natural gas versus conventional marine fuels.

Entitled: 'Natural Gas for Waterborne Freight Transport: A Life Cycle Emissions Assessment with Case Studies', the study was conducted as a part of MARAD's Maritime Environmental and Technology Assistance Program, which focuses efforts on emerging marine transportation and environmental issues.

The study was prepared for MARAD by the University of Delaware and The Rochester Institute of Technology.

Commenting on the results of the study, MARAD said in a statement: "Results of the study showed that the use of natural gas as a propulsion fuel can reduce air quality pollutants and reduce major greenhouse gas emissions when compared to conventional fuels. The information provided by this study is important as marine transportation stakeholders evaluate the use of natural gas as aviable alternative propulsion fuel for reducing air polluting emissions."

In the concluding section of the study entitled: 'Overall Results and Discussion', the report says: "When comparing emissions produced using natural gas or traditional diesel fuel, results were mixed as to which would produce the fewest emissions. The total energy needed to make the trip is higher in the natural gas scenarios, as is the amount of CH4, N2O, and NOx produced. In the all-diesel scenarios (both diesel main and auxiliary engines) more CO2, PM10, and SOx are produced. Additionally, when taking into account the global warming potential of CH4, N2O, and CO2, LNG fuel is found in coastal scenarios (both West Coast and East Coast) to produce less overall GHG emissions (as measured in CO2 equivalent units) than diesel fuel scenarios using either low-sulfur distillate (depending upon pathway) or high-sulfur residual fuel. Diesel in inland river scenarios results in less overall GHG emissions (as measured in CO2 equivalent units). Diesel in the West Coast scenario results in more overall GHG emissions (as measured in CO2 equivalent units) under either low-sulfur distillate (depending on pathway) or high-sulfur residual fuels (across all natural gas pathways). Diesel in the East Coast scenario also results in more overall GHG emissions (as measured in CO2 equivalent units) under either low-sulfur distillate (depending on pathway) or high-sulfur residual fuels (across all natural gas pathways). While this analysis does not include an assessment of impacts resulting from each of those pollutants, one can consider the fact that the IMO deemed NOx and SOx both important enough pollutants to regulate.

"This is an important consideration. Natural gas is considered by many to be a win-win-win marine fuel: i) economically attractive; ii) low-emitting for key air quality pollutants; and iii) lower GHGs (primarily lower CO2). However, natural gas may achieve some goals better than others. Other studies have found that switching to natural gas does not improve GHG emissions, especially considering methane leakage impacts on global warming potential (Brynolf, Magnusson, Fridell, & Andersson, 2013; Lowell et al., 2013; Meyer et al., 2011). This study did find a small but positive GHG benefit along with economic and local/regional air quality benefits.

"These results support conclusions made by some previous studies. Bengtsson, Andersson, and Fridell (2011) concluded that natural gas did reduce the amount of GHGs emitted. Their results are consistent with lower emissions factors and leakage rates that have since been updated (Burnham et al., 2013). A later work (S. K. Bengtsson, Fridell, & Andersson, 2014), also found that LNG has a slightly better GHG potential than diesel fuel."

The full 111-page study can be viewed by clicking on the following link below.

Natural Gas for Waterborne Freight Transport: A Life Cycle Emissions Assessment with Case Studies


Molslinjen vessel render. AYK Energy secures battery contract for Molslinjen's electric fast ferries  

Battery maker to supply 165MWh for three electric catamarans after cutting system weight by nearly half.

Giosue Vezzuto, RINA. Giosuè Vezzuto named CEO of RINA Services, taking charge of marine and certification arm  

Naval engineer with nearly three decades at RINA succeeds Paolo Moretti to lead the group's marine and certification division.

Acta Aquarius vessel. Acta Marine completes four-vessel newbuild programme with delivery of methanol dual-fuel Acta Aquarius  

Dutch offshore support vessel operator takes delivery of its fourth Tersan-built CSOV, featuring dual-fuel methanol propulsion.

Wind-assisted vessel illustration. Lloyd's Register backs GCMD methodology for verifying wind propulsion fuel savings  

Independent review aims to boost confidence in wind-assisted propulsion performance and unlock sustainable finance for energy-efficiency retrofits.

CM Wuhan vessel. China Merchants delivers first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by CCS  

The 7,800-CEU CM Wuhan is the first methanol dual-fuel ro-ro vessel classed solely by China Classification Society.

Andre M ammonia-fuelled gas carrier. China delivers first domestically built ammonia-fuelled gas carrier  

CCS-classed vessel becomes the world's second ammonia-fuelled gas carrier, testing rules for the IMO's zero-carbon shipping transition.

Nordion Energi liquefied biogas (LBG) facility render. Storage tank installed as Gothenburg's LBG bunkering plant advances towards 2027 completion  

Nordion Energi's liquefied biogas facility at the Port of Gothenburg takes a step forward with tank installation.

Maran Myron vessel. Maran Tankers takes delivery of dual-fuel Suezmax Maran Myron  

Vessel is sixth dual-fuel tanker in eight-vessel series built by New Times Shipbuilding.

Lake Victoria truck-to-ship (TTS) bunkering operation. EPS completes first truck-to-ship LNG bunkering operation in Davisville  

Fuel delivered to the pure car and truck carrier Lake Victoria whilst at berth.

Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore logo. MPA opens applications for LNG floating storage unit licences  

Singapore invites applications for up to two LNG floating storage unit licences to bolster bunkering supply resilience.