This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Thu 8 Feb 2018, 12:13 GMT

Scorpio Bulkers COO voices scrubber 'scepticism' once again


Scrubber legislation, existing technology and the availability of fuels in 2020 all 'stand in the way' of long-term decision making, says Mackey.



The chief operating officer (COO) of dry bulk vessel owner/operator Scorpio Bulkers Inc, Cameron Mackey, has once again voiced his company's scepticism regarding current regulations for exhaust gas scrubbers and existing technology.

Speaking during the firm's last earnings call, Mackey explained that he believed it was just a question of time before scrubber standards are addressed again - potentially resulting in additional costs for companies with the technology already installed.

"It is ironic... that decarbonization can be left up to a ship that is out of sight and out of the reach of many regulators. So, in other words, I think it is only a matter of time before these regulators revisit the scrubber solution and realize that a scrubber takes emissions and instead of putting them into the air, actually puts them into the sea," Mackey said.

"So, we have a healthy scepticism that regulations, as they are now, will not be changed or modified, and that's one of the greatest risks that any ship owner - not just us - has in undertaking an expensive capital project... It's the risk that regulations change, either in implementation or around the technology," the Scorpio Bulkers COO added.

Discussing the design of existing scrubbers, Mackey appeared to suggest that there was concern amongst ship owners about whether the technology "is actually adequately designed and resilient".

"There are tales and case studies of those who have installed scrubbers already in the cruise industry - and some [in] the short sea shipping industry - that indicate that this technology, even as it is currently, may not be adequate to address the objectives that the regulators are putting out there," Mackey explained.

Mackey concluded that "these risks are so great that it would be really foolhardy to undertake that type of investment now".

Mackey added that the aforementioned factors, in addition to uncertainty regarding the availability of fuels in 2020, as well as pricing, were all factors that "stand in the way" of long-term decision making.

However, the Scorpio Bulkers director stressed that the company was "in a privileged position" compared to other ship owners due to the fuel efficiency of its fleet.

As Bunker Index previously reported, Mackey has voiced his concerns regarding scrubber technology before. In April 2017, he said the company believed it was "only a matter of time" before it becomes a legal requirement to use closed-loop scrubbers - where exhaust gases are washed and harmful substances collected in a tank, rather than being discharged into the sea.

Financial results

In its financial results for 2017, Scorpio Bulkers posted a net loss of $59.7 million compared to a net loss of $124.8 million the previous year.

For the fourth quarter (Q4), a net loss of $1.1 million was recorded, which was an improvement on the net loss of $20.6 million in Q4 2016.


Verde Marine Energy and Sunoco LP logos. Sunoco and Verde Marine Energy announce commercial collaboration in ARA and UK bunker markets  

Partnership aims to combine Sunoco's Americas reach with Verde's Northern European supply platform.

CMA CGM Berenice vessel. CMA CGM methanol dual-fuel vessel makes first call at Malta Freeport  

Berenice is fifth in a six-ship series of methanol dual-fuel vessels being introduced by the French shipping group.

Everllence 16V175D engine render. Everllence's 175D engine wins offshore tug order from Türkiye  

Sixteen gensets are bound for four Rampage 6000-DE terminal tugs destined for Guyana.

NSD 75CC vessel design render. NSD wins BioMar fish feed vessel contract with hybrid propulsion design  

The NSD 75CC will feature a hybrid system combining electric and direct diesel-mechanical propulsion.

CCS type approval for All-scenario methanol single-fuel engine CCS awards type approval to China’s first all-scenario high-pressure direct-injection methanol medium-speed marine engine  

China Classification Society certifies SMDERI’s methanol single-fuel engine.

Carnot multi-fuel engine. Carnot tests engine on biodiesel as multi-fuel development programme advances  

UK engine developer Carnot has run its engine on biodiesel, adding to prior diesel and hydrogen tests.

IBIA logo. IBIA to hold mass flow meter training course in Rotterdam as industry reflects on first months of implementation  

One-day course covers MFM technology, regulatory frameworks and practical bunkering experience.

AQUBE battery system. Sunlight Group subsidiary lands first order for AQUBE liquid-cooled battery system for DLR research vessel  

A 48-metre floating technology platform will test hydrogen, hybrid and electric propulsion systems at sea.

Fure Vasa vessel. Furetank to name LBM-fuelled Fure Vasa as Swedish-flagged fleet reaches 105 ships  

Vessel to run primarily on liquefied biomethane (LBM) within the EU and is equipped for shore power connection.

Mitsui-Everllence 7S60ME engine. Mitsui E&S completes commercialisation of ammonia dual-fuel engines and fuel supply systems  

Japanese manufacturer says it is now ready to supply ammonia propulsion systems for actual vessels.


↑  Back to Top