Tue 5 May 2009, 15:32 GMT

Study: 'Green Gateway' is lowest emission route


Survey says West Coast route offers the lowest carbon footprint for cargoes from Asia.



The ports of Seattle and Tacoma have announced the results of a study that quantifies the carbon footprint of containers coming through the Puget Sound and concluded that the lowest emission route to ship cargo from Asia to the U.S. Midwest is through the Puget Sound – the “Green Gateway” for trade.

“The carbon study results are good news, and a great boost to our efforts to measure and reduce our environmental impact,” said Port of Seattle CEO Tay Yoshitani. “Our ongoing sustainability initiatives have created a ‘Green Gateway’ that is good for our environment and our customers.”

The study, commissioned by the Port of Seattle, was conducted by Herbert Engineering, a ship design, engineering and transportation consulting firm based in California.

The analysts looked at the carbon footprints of trade routes between Singapore, Hong Kong, and Shanghai, and the U.S. distribution hubs of Chicago, Columbus and Memphis as well as rail routes through the ports of Prince Rupert, Seattle, Oakland, and Los Angeles/Long Beach.

The study also analyzed routes via the Panama and Suez Canals through the ports of Houston, Savannah, Norfolk and New York. Ships sized at 4,500, 6,500, 8,500, and 12,500 TEUs (twenty-foot equivalent units) were included in the survey, as was the expansion of the Panama Canal in 2014.

According to the study, Puget Sound ports have a clear advantage in greenhouse gas emissions compared to East Coast ports for intermodal shipments from Asia to the Midwest.

It also concluded that while ocean transportation emits less carbon per container TEU (twenty-foot equivalent unit) on a per-mile basis than rail, the ocean distance to West Coast ports is short enough to offset the carbon impact of rail transportation from the West Coast to inland destinations.

Even in 2014, when the Panama Canal expansion is complete and larger ships begin to transit the canal, West Coast ports will maintain their carbon emissions advantage, the study said.

The effort to measure carbon footprints along trade routes is the latest step taken by the Puget Sound ports to quantify and reduce air emissions from maritime sources.

The Ports of Seattle and Tacoma partnered on the first maritime air emissions inventory for the Puget Sound region. Initiated in 2006, the Puget Sound Maritime Air Emissions Inventory is said to be the first to include greenhouse gas emissions. The study provided scientific data on the nature and extent of air emissions from maritime sources in the Puget Sound and Georgia Basin Airshed.

The Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy – a joint effort of the Port of Seattle, Port of Tacoma and Port Metro Vancouver – used the data from the inventory as a starting point for establishing emissions reductions benchmarks. The Clean Air Strategy establishes specific goals and dates for reducing emissions from ships, cargo-handling equipment and trucks that move cargo to and from the ports.

The goal of all of these efforts was to make the gateway more efficient and competitive, improve air quality, and reduce costs.

"The Puget Sound Maritime Air Emissions Inventory and Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy are groundbreaking documents. They are unique not only because of the kind of information they contain, but also because of the cooperative approach they represent. The Ports have worked hand-in-hand with the transportation industry, regulatory agencies, community organizations, labor and environmental advocates. That cooperative approach has helped us move farther, faster without adding fees for port users," the Port of Seattle said.

"The Port of Seattle has taken a leading role to ensure that such policies are based on sound data, working with World Ports Climate Initiative members to develop guidelines all ports can use to measure the carbon footprint of their operations," the Port added.

Green actions to date

In 2005, Princess Cruises joined with the Port of Seattle, the Environmental Protection Agency, the Puget Sound Clean Air Agency (PSCAA) and Seattle City Light to bring the first shore power connection to the Pacific Northwest. Holland America Line followed in 2006 with a second connection.

These shorepower connections reduce green house gas emissions by 29 percent per vessel call. All cruise ships calling that do not connect to shore power are required to use fuels with a sulfur content of 1.5 percent or less, reducing particulate matter emissions.

In January 2009, the Port of Seattle and PSCAA implemented the At-berth Clean Fuels (ABC Fuels) program, which provides incentives for container ship operators to use low sulfur fuel (0.5% or less) while the vessels are docked in Seattle.

As of April 2009, six carriers have signed up for the program (Maersk Line, CMA CGM, APL, Matson Navigation, Hapag Lloyd and Norwegian Cruise Line) and several others are considering participation. ABC Fuels is expected to reduce emissions of particulate matter from participating ships by 60 percent and sulfur dioxide by 95 percent. More than half of the ships that call frequently at the Port of Tacoma voluntarily burn cleaner, low sulfur distillate fuels while docked in Tacoma.

"The approach of both ports through all of these steps has been to partner with customers, tenants, community groups, environmental organizations and regulatory agencies. The result has been effective solutions that keep the port competitive and do not increase costs for shippers or carriers," the Port of Seattle said.


Yanmar Maritime awarded DNV type approval for fuel cell system. Yanmar Maritime receives DNV type approval for hydrogen fuel cell system at SMM  

The GH-FC series certification is aimed at easing adoption of hydrogen propulsion across vessel types.

Euwyn Tan, Flex Commodities. Flex Commodities appoints senior marine fuels trader in Singapore  

Euwyn Tan joins Flex Commodities FZCO to strengthen its marine fuels trading operations in Asia.

Closing ceremony of vessel with builder's hull no. 0208121. LNG dual-fuel boxship handed over to Eastern Pacific Shipping  

Closing ceremony held in Jingjiang for 8,400-TEU container vessel.

Everllence's 175D high-speed engine render. Everllence and Damen sign framework agreement for serial supply of 175D engines  

Agreement covers high-speed engine supply for Damen’s fuel-flexible tug programme and beyond.

IINO Lines and BGN signing. IINO Lines signs time charter deal with BGN for LPG dual-fuel VLGC  

Japanese shipowner’s fourth LPG dual-fuel vessel will offer rare dual-canal Panama Canal transit capability.

Lubmarine drum. TotalEnergies Lubmarine launches fuel-economy lubricant for four-stroke medium-speed marine engines  

Aurelia FE claims fuel savings of 1.5% on a standardised test cycle, with no vessel modifications required.

Sunrui and Lloyd’s Register at SMM 2026. LR validates CFD analysis for SunRui suction sail technology  

Independent verification confirms aerodynamic modelling meets recognised industry standards for wind-assisted propulsion.

Orlen and Port of Gdynia partnership signing. Orlen and Port of Gdynia partner to explore LNG and bio-LNG bunkering options  

Agreement signed to assess LNG and bio-LNG bunkering potential along the Polish coast.

North Sea Trading logo. North Sea Trading appoints head of renewable fuels and signs India green methanol MoU  

Industry veteran Robert Preston joins Bournemouth-based bunker trading firm.

Windward Hamburg vessel. VARD delivers final CSOV to Windward Offshore, completing series  

Methanol-ready Windward Hamburg joins the fleet as VARD completes delivery of four purpose-built CSOVs.