Tue 16 Jan 2024 16:22 | Updated: Tue 16 Jan 2024 16:23

ISO 8217 formula 'not suitable' for gauging FAME fuel energy content: VPS


Accurate measurement can only be determined using calorimetry, says testing firm.


Algebra illustration.
VPS says the ISO 8217 equation is able to calculate the energy content of conventional fuels and distillates to a good degree of accuracy because of the empirical linear relationship between density and energy content; but this relationship does not hold when the fuel contains oxygenated compounds, such as FAME in biodiesel. Image: Pixabay

VPS has published a white paper where it asserts that the existing ISO 8217 formula for calculating energy content — a key test parameter — is not accurate for fuels containing FAME, such as biodiesel.[1]

Energy content represents the amount of heat transferred within the combustion chamber during the burn process and indicates the available energy from the fuel. Higher energy content results in higher power generation and better combustion efficiency. The energy content has a direct impact on fuel economy and greenhouse gas emissions and is therefore an important parameter for ship operators to consider in preparation for the EU ETS.

In the VPS research paper, a number of conventional fossil fuels and biofuels with varying FAME content were measured using the ASTM D240 method and the energy content compared with that obtained using the ISO 8217 calculation method (which uses a formula specified in Appendix H of the International Marine Fuel Standard ISO 8217:2017).

The results show good correlation for conventional fuels and distillates, indicating that the ISO 8217 calculation method provides an acceptable degree of accuracy for measuring energy content in conventional fuel types. However, according to VPS, this correlation falls away at FAME content above 10%, thus demonstrating that the ISO 8217 calculation method cannot be relied upon to provide accurate energy content for fuel blends containing more than 10% FAME and that, for these blends, the accuracy of the calculation formula is not acceptable, and accurate energy content can only be determined by measurement using calorimetry.

"This inaccuracy," VPS says, "is due to the greater oxygen content of FAME ... as compared to conventional fuels (which typically contain very little oxygen)."

The ISO 8217 formula is only based on the linear relationship between density and energy content, VPS explains, but does not account for oxygen present in FAME.

As the FAME and the oxygen in the FAME are both variables, a linear relationship between the FAME and the energy content could therefore not be established in studies carried out on biofuels with varying FAME content.

For blends containing more than 10% FAME, VPS concludes that the accurate assessment of energy content requires direct measurement (rather than an equation calculation) using the ASTM D240 method, which uses an oxygen bomb calorimeter to determine the energy content.


Notes

[1] Sign up to a subscription plan to view notes and source information.

Preemraff Göteborg, Preem's wholly owned refinery in Gothenburg, Sweden. VARO Energy expands renewable portfolio with Preem acquisition  

All-cash transaction expected to complete in the latter half of 2025.

Pictured: Biofuel is supplied to NYK Line's Noshiro Maru. The vessel tested biofuel for Tohoku Electric Power in a landmark first for Japan. NYK trials biofuel in milestone coal carrier test  

Vessel is used to test biofuel for domestic utility company.

Pictured (from left): H-Line Shipping CEO Seo Myungdeuk and HJSC CEO Yoo Sang-cheol at the contract signing ceremony for the construction of an 18,000-cbm LNG bunkering vessel. H-Line Shipping orders LNG bunkering vessel  

Vessel with 18,000-cbm capacity to run on both LNG and MDO.

Stanley George, VPS Group Technical and Science Manager, VPS. How to engineer and manage green shipping fuels | Stanley George, VPS  

Effective management strategies and insights for evolving fuel use.

Sweden flag with water in background. Swedish government bans scrubber wastewater discharges  

Discharges from open-loop scrubbers to be prohibited in Swedish waters from July 2025.

The ME-LGIA test engine at MAN's Research Centre Copenhagen. MAN Energy Solutions achieves 100% load milestone for ammonia engine  

Latest tests validate fuel injection system throughout the entire load curve.

Terminal Aquaviário de Rio Grande (TERIG), operated by Transpetro. Petrobras secures ISCC EU RED certification for B24 biofuel blend at Rio Grande  

Blend consisting of 24% FAME is said to have been rigorously tested to meet international standards.

Avenir LNG logo on sea background. Stolt-Nielsen to fully control Avenir LNG with acquisition  

Share purchase agreement to buy all shares from Golar LNG and Aequitas.

Seaspan Energy's 7,600 cbm LNG bunkering vessel, s1067, built by Nantong CIMC Sinopacific Offshore & Engineering Co., Ltd. Bureau Veritas supports launch of CIMC SOE's LNG bunkering vessel  

Handover of Seaspan Energy's cutting-edge 7,600-cbm vessel completed.

The world's first methanol-fuelled container ship, Laura Maersk. Methanol as a marine fuel | Steve Bee, VPS  

How environmental legislation has driven the development of low-sulphur fuels and methanol-ready ships.


↑  Back to Top