Wed 4 Jul 2012 08:51

Lubmarine defends universal lubricant concept


Supplier says all of its customers can operate in the knowledge they are not risking damage to their engine.



Total Lubmarine (Lubmarine), one of the world’s leading global suppliers of marine lubricants and greases, has expressed concern over recent information released to the market suggesting that ship owners and operators must choose a high or a low BN marine cylinder lubricant (MCL) based upon their predominant operating patterns.

Lubmarine says it agrees that general operations for 2-stroke diesel engines are becoming more severe, increasing the technical challenges required for deposit control, cleanliness and wear protection. However over the past decade, the company says conventional MCL wisdom has changed and "it has been clearly proven that the BN argument is now an outdated one."

"This is because BN alone is simply not enough to explain the neutralisation performance of a lubricant. As such, Total Lubmarine believes that the implications of this ‘high BN with conventional chemistry’ approach are at best risky and at worst dangerous," the company explained.

Jean-Philippe Roman, technical director, commented: “It is important to note that it is not the level of basicity that is dangerous, but the underlying chemistry with which products are formulated. For anyone relying upon the conventional MCL chemistry - which the majority of lubricant suppliers now recognise as outdated – it is understandable that the only option is to increase the BN. However this presents a high-risk strategy; too low a BN for the sulphur content can lead to acid corrosion of the liners, whilst too high a BN can lead to hard calcium deposits and an increased risk of bore polishing and liner scuffing.”

Lubmarine believes that suggestions that ships choosing a high or low BN lubricant based upon their predominant operating patterns will only have to carry one cylinder oil is not only restrictive but also potentially dangerous. Without a back up providing the option to switch between high and low sulphur fuels and corresponding MCLs, Lubmarine says certain route changes would prove impossible and operational safety could be compromised.

"Although an increasingly isolated minority is polarising itself from the innovators and early adopters of single oil solutions, with five year's experience of operating using this new chemistry, Total Lubmarine's knowledge of it is maturing, data continues to accumulate and evidence is conclusive confirming that this is absolutely the right direction for MCLs. Moreover, this is a position that is substantiated by others at the forefront of the MCL marketplace that also subscribe to the same thinking and have recently launched new 'single solution' lubricants into the marketplace," Lubmarine said.

Lubmarine says it agrees that any new cylinder lubricant launched to the market must be tested in all extremes, and not just in the conditions that suit the product. "Operating under slow steaming conditions absolutely demands superior wear control and five years of 'at sea' evaluation underlines that the "universal" concept is proven to be reliable. With more than 2,000 samples from slow steaming vessels, Total Lubmarine can attest that the iron measured in the drain oil – which denotes engine wear – is lower with its newest multipurpose MCL than with a conventional mid- or high-BN lubricant. Furthermore, Lubmarine's Talusia Universal product is approved by leading two-stroke engine manufacturers MAN Diesel & Turbo, Wärtsilä and Mitsubishi HI," the lubricant supplier said.

Jean-Philippe Roman added: "New industry realities require new thinking from MCL suppliers. Single oil solutions may represent a paradigm shift for the industry but they are also a breakthrough in product applicability for shipowners and operators facing unprecedented economic and environmental challenges. Universal lubricants are conclusively proven to meet vessel needs in all operating conditions, so whether slow steaming or transiting ECAs, all of our customers can operate in the knowledge they are not risking damage to their engine."

Preemraff Göteborg, Preem's wholly owned refinery in Gothenburg, Sweden. VARO Energy expands renewable portfolio with Preem acquisition  

All-cash transaction expected to complete in the latter half of 2025.

Pictured: Biofuel is supplied to NYK Line's Noshiro Maru. The vessel tested biofuel for Tohoku Electric Power in a landmark first for Japan. NYK trials biofuel in milestone coal carrier test  

Vessel is used to test biofuel for domestic utility company.

Pictured (from left): H-Line Shipping CEO Seo Myungdeuk and HJSC CEO Yoo Sang-cheol at the contract signing ceremony for the construction of an 18,000-cbm LNG bunkering vessel. H-Line Shipping orders LNG bunkering vessel  

Vessel with 18,000-cbm capacity to run on both LNG and MDO.

Stanley George, VPS Group Technical and Science Manager, VPS. How to engineer and manage green shipping fuels | Stanley George, VPS  

Effective management strategies and insights for evolving fuel use.

Sweden flag with water in background. Swedish government bans scrubber wastewater discharges  

Discharges from open-loop scrubbers to be prohibited in Swedish waters from July 2025.

The ME-LGIA test engine at MAN's Research Centre Copenhagen. MAN Energy Solutions achieves 100% load milestone for ammonia engine  

Latest tests validate fuel injection system throughout the entire load curve.

Terminal Aquaviário de Rio Grande (TERIG), operated by Transpetro. Petrobras secures ISCC EU RED certification for B24 biofuel blend at Rio Grande  

Blend consisting of 24% FAME is said to have been rigorously tested to meet international standards.

Avenir LNG logo on sea background. Stolt-Nielsen to fully control Avenir LNG with acquisition  

Share purchase agreement to buy all shares from Golar LNG and Aequitas.

Seaspan Energy's 7,600 cbm LNG bunkering vessel, s1067, built by Nantong CIMC Sinopacific Offshore & Engineering Co., Ltd. Bureau Veritas supports launch of CIMC SOE's LNG bunkering vessel  

Handover of Seaspan Energy's cutting-edge 7,600-cbm vessel completed.

The world's first methanol-fuelled container ship, Laura Maersk. Methanol as a marine fuel | Steve Bee, VPS  

How environmental legislation has driven the development of low-sulphur fuels and methanol-ready ships.


↑  Back to Top