Tue 9 Sep 2008, 08:03 GMT

Study: Cleaner fuels have zero GHG impact


Researchers claim use of cleaner fuels has a net zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.



A new study carried out in the United States claims to demonstrate that the production and distribution of "cleaner" marine fuels creates a net zero impact on greenhouse gas emissions.

James Winebrake, Professor and Chair of the Department of Science, Technology and Society/Public Policy at Rochester Institute of Technology, and James Corbett, associate professor in the College of Marine and Earth Studies at the University of Delaware examined "Emission Tradeoffs among Alternative Marine Fuels: Total Fuel Cycle Analysis of Residual Oil, Marine Gas Oil, and Marine Diesel Oil," in a recent issue of Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association.

According to Winebrake and Corbett, reducing fuel sulphur content is an essential component of any strategy aimed at reducing sulphur oxide emissions from marine vessels - especially since global concerns have caused policy makers to accelerate the introduction of emission control technologies and cleaner fuels into the international marine sector. These tactics aim to improve air quality and human health and mitigate climate change.

"Cleaner fuels are expected to reduce sulfur and particulate emissions, however, greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions may increase because of the additional refining energy required to produce these fuels - residual oil, marine gas oil and marine diesel oil," Winebrake explained. "Our study provides a total fuel cycle emissions analysis to help quantify these emissions tradeoffs."

In the study, the two professors applied a jointly developed model called the Total Energy and Emissions Analysis for Marine Systems (TEAMS) model, which was developed to explore what are called "upstream" emissions associated with fuel production and distribution. Using the model, the authors reportedly demonstrated that although cleaner fuels increase GHG emissions during their production, they reduce GHG emissions during vessel operation, creating almost a net zero GHG impact.

The result was counter to claims which suggested that the use of cleaner fuels in the marine sector would exacerbate GHG problems.

"Given that the GHG impacts associated with cleaner fuels are almost nil, and given the tremendous advantages of these fuels with respect to other pollutants, policies that encourage cleaner fuels seem warranted," said Winebrake, who also published a paper last year with Corbett reportedly demonstrating significant premature human mortality across the globe due to emissions from ships.

"The global shipping sector is one of the last unregulated emissions sources, and our study will provide useful information to the ongoing international debate surrounding cleaner marine fuels," said Winebrake.


Illustration of a high-speed dual-fuel engine. Nanni develops first high-speed methanol dual-fuel engine with ScandiNAOS  

French manufacturer tests John Deere-based genset running on 70% methanol, 30% diesel blend.

Capital's LNG dual-fuel tanker vessel. New Times Shipbuilding delivers LNG dual-fuel tanker to Capital  

Chinese shipyard hands over 112,500-dwt vessel capable of running on LNG or conventional fuel.

Fuel for Thought: LPG report. Lloyd’s Register examines LPG as marine fuel in new research report  

Classification society evaluates LPG emissions benefits, safety considerations and technology readiness for shipping.

Steel-cutting ceremony for vessel with builder's hull no. W0284. Finnlines begins construction of first methanol-capable ro-pax vessel in EUR 500m newbuild programme  

Grimaldi Group subsidiary begins work on Hansa Superstar class ships at Chinese shipyard.

Navios Cyan vessel. Navios Partners takes delivery of LNG- and methanol-ready boxship  

The 7,900-teu Navios Cyan is the first of four newbuildings in the series.

Rendering of a hydrogen energy system. Floating hydrogen power hub validated for grid-independent ship charging at berth  

ELIRE Maritime-led consortium validates modular platform delivering 5MW of clean power without a shoreside grid connection.

Kota Ocean ship-to-ship (STS) LNG bunkering operation. PIL completes first LNG bunkering at Shanghai’s Mingdong Terminal  

Kota Ocean took on 4,300-cbm of LNG during simultaneous cargo operations.

Fully electric passenger ferry render. Estonia orders first fully electric ferry from Polish shipyard CRIST  

Battery-powered vessel designed by LMG Marin will operate on the Virtsu–Kuivastu route from 2028.

Eco Levant vessel. X-Press Feeders trials ethanol-methanol blend in Rotterdam  

Container operator tests 10-90 ethanol-methanol fuel mix aboard Eco Levant vessel.

Venture Energy, CSST and CSTC MoU signing. Venture Energy signs green methanol cooperation agreement  

MoU establishes framework for long-term offtake and capacity development in maritime decarbonisation.