This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Mon 4 Jun 2018, 09:57 GMT

OW Bunker ruling threatens uncertainty for 'hundreds' of cases: ING


ING files petition for rehearing, arguing that Florida law has been applied at the expense of maritime law.


Image credit: Pixabay
ING Bank has filed a petition for rehearing following the recent decision by the United States Court of Appeals to uphold a judgment made by a court in the Northern District of Florida, which ruled that physical supplier Martin Energy Services LLC should receive $286,200 plus interest for the supply of 300 metric tonnes of marine fuel to the vessel Bravante VIII in a deal involving the now-defunct business OW Bunker.

As previously reported, ING - as the lead participant in a syndicate that provided working capital for OW Bunker entities prior to their collapse - had appealed the district court's initial judgment that OW Bunker should receive $3,900, which was effectively the sales margin that the firm would have recorded as a back-to-back trader in the $290,100 direct deal it had with the buyer.

ING had asserted that the court had erred by awarding Martin the aforementioned payout for supplying the fuel, arguing that the bunkering certificate did not give rise to a contract between Martin and buyer Boldini; that there had been no direct contact between both companies; and that the vessel that received the fuel had already left the jurisdiction of the court, so it could not adjudicate in rem lien rights against the Bravante VIII.

And in its petition for rehearing, ING argued that the decision to allow the supplier to recover in quantum meruit - i.e. based on the reasonable value of services provided - meant that Florida law was being applied at the expense of "the uniformity of admiralty law".

ING asked the court if a rehearing should be granted in order to "prevent this decision from undermining the principle of uniformity in federal maritime law".

The financial services firm went on to suggest that "this conflict threatens uncertainty around hundreds of litigations arising from the OW Bunker collapse in November 2014 that have proceeded worldwide".

Barcliff, LLC v. M/V Deep Blue

ING also referred to the OW Bunker-related case Barcliff, LLC v. M/V Deep Blue, where a court decreed that Radcliff did not possess a maritime lien for the bunker stem it delivered to the Deep Blue in November 2014, and that ING did have a maritime lien by virtue of OW Bunkers UK's assignment of that right in the Security Agreement.

"It is unfortunate that Radcliff supplied the fuel and was not paid. But by entering into a contractual relationship exclusively with O.W. USA, Radcliff became O.W. USA's creditor. It is assuredly not the only one. O.W. USA's other creditors are doubtless vying for repayment in bankruptcy court. Rather than pursue its claim there, Radcliff elected to go after Technip for the full amount by asserting a lien on the Deep Blue, even though Technip purchased the fuel from O.W. UK and was contractually obligated to pay O.W. UK for it. It was Radcliff's right to gamble, but its choice should elicit no sympathy," ING said.

ING noted that, just like Radcliff in the Barcliff case, Martin "effectively ignored its contractual claim against OWBUSA, and gambled on obtaining the full amount of its claim by asserting a quantum meruit claim against the vessel owner." But unlike Barcliff, Martin won its case.

Triple liability

In its petition for rehearing, ING suggests the decision to grant Martin $286,200 had created a scenario where a vessel and its owner could be subjected to triple liability - once in rem, for failure to pay its counterparty, subjecting the vessel to a statutory maritime lien claim, and twice in personam - once to the physical supplier under principles of Florida law where that law applies, and once to ING (as assignee of the applicable OWB entity) under English contract law for the invoice amount.

ING is requesting that the court grants a rehearing; reverses the district court's judgment; finds that Martin has no legal claim to the funds; and orders disbursement of the funds to ING.


Fincantieri logo. Fincantieri secures order for two LNG dual-fuel cruise ships from Carnival  

Carnival Corporation orders two dual-fuel, LNG-powered cruise ships from Fincantieri for delivery in 2033 and 2035.

RAstar 4200 tug render. Robert Allan to design escort tugs for Safeen Drydocks fleet bound for Africa  

Six RAstar-series escort tugs will be built in Dubai for harbour, terminal and firefighting operations in Africa.

Claudene Sharp-Patel, Lloyd's Register. Lloyd's Register approves classification rules for nuclear-powered ships and offshore units  

Class society publishes reactor-agnostic framework to help assess nuclear propulsion and power for maritime applications.

Frank Nieuwenhuis, Econowind. Econowind marks ten years as wind-assisted propulsion gains ground in shipping  

Dutch company moves from car-roof prototypes to more than 170 VentoFoil units sold, as fuel costs and emissions rules push wind propulsion into the mainstream.

Purus Vortex vessel. Damen delivers first CSOV to Purus for methanol-ready offshore wind support  

Purus Vortex, Damen's first CSOV for the operator, will support North Sea offshore wind operations from IJmuiden.

WinGD and Hanwha Engine collaboration agreement signing ceremony. WinGD and Hanwha Engine expand collaboration ahead of new engine launches  

The companies will work together on bringing WinGD's X-DF-HP LNG and X-DF-P LPG engines to market.

Castrol Logo. Castrol teams up with Stone Oil to expand marine lubricant supply on US Gulf Coast  

Partnership gives Gulf Coast vessel operators direct access to Castrol Seamax lubricants through Stone Oil's distribution network.

Keel-laying ceremony for Natalia Cosulich. Keel laid for Natalia Cosulich, final vessel in Cosulich's methanol-ready tanker series  

Fratelli Cosulich Marine Energy marks construction milestone for the fourth bunker tanker in its fleet expansion programme.

Titan Clean Fuels logo. Titan Clean Fuels seeks commercial manager to grow LNG bunkering business  

Amsterdam-based LNG bunker supplier advertises role to expand marine fuel sales and manage vessel scheduling.

Reception area at Monjasa's Singapore office. Monjasa seeks supply trader to join Singapore operation  

Experience in Singapore's bunker supply industry required; fluency in Mandarin an advantage.


↑  Back to Top