This is a legacy page. Please click here to view the latest version.
Thu 8 Feb 2018, 12:13 GMT

Scorpio Bulkers COO voices scrubber 'scepticism' once again


Scrubber legislation, existing technology and the availability of fuels in 2020 all 'stand in the way' of long-term decision making, says Mackey.



The chief operating officer (COO) of dry bulk vessel owner/operator Scorpio Bulkers Inc, Cameron Mackey, has once again voiced his company's scepticism regarding current regulations for exhaust gas scrubbers and existing technology.

Speaking during the firm's last earnings call, Mackey explained that he believed it was just a question of time before scrubber standards are addressed again - potentially resulting in additional costs for companies with the technology already installed.

"It is ironic... that decarbonization can be left up to a ship that is out of sight and out of the reach of many regulators. So, in other words, I think it is only a matter of time before these regulators revisit the scrubber solution and realize that a scrubber takes emissions and instead of putting them into the air, actually puts them into the sea," Mackey said.

"So, we have a healthy scepticism that regulations, as they are now, will not be changed or modified, and that's one of the greatest risks that any ship owner - not just us - has in undertaking an expensive capital project... It's the risk that regulations change, either in implementation or around the technology," the Scorpio Bulkers COO added.

Discussing the design of existing scrubbers, Mackey appeared to suggest that there was concern amongst ship owners about whether the technology "is actually adequately designed and resilient".

"There are tales and case studies of those who have installed scrubbers already in the cruise industry - and some [in] the short sea shipping industry - that indicate that this technology, even as it is currently, may not be adequate to address the objectives that the regulators are putting out there," Mackey explained.

Mackey concluded that "these risks are so great that it would be really foolhardy to undertake that type of investment now".

Mackey added that the aforementioned factors, in addition to uncertainty regarding the availability of fuels in 2020, as well as pricing, were all factors that "stand in the way" of long-term decision making.

However, the Scorpio Bulkers director stressed that the company was "in a privileged position" compared to other ship owners due to the fuel efficiency of its fleet.

As Bunker Index previously reported, Mackey has voiced his concerns regarding scrubber technology before. In April 2017, he said the company believed it was "only a matter of time" before it becomes a legal requirement to use closed-loop scrubbers - where exhaust gases are washed and harmful substances collected in a tank, rather than being discharged into the sea.

Financial results

In its financial results for 2017, Scorpio Bulkers posted a net loss of $59.7 million compared to a net loss of $124.8 million the previous year.

For the fourth quarter (Q4), a net loss of $1.1 million was recorded, which was an improvement on the net loss of $20.6 million in Q4 2016.


Maran Melina vessel. Angelicoussis Group takes delivery of fifth dual-fuel Suezmax tanker  

Maran Tankers Management adds the 155,500-DWT Maran Melina to its fleet.

CMA CGM Orsay naming ceremony. CMA CGM takes delivery of LNG-powered Orsay for Asia-Europe trade  

24,212-TEU vessel joins 10-ship series, adding capacity to the carrier's FAL3 route.

Titan Unikum vessel. Titan Clean Fuels completes 15-year survey on LNG bunkering vessel Titan Unikum  

Multi-gas carrier has undergone dry-docking work at a Chinese yard, preparing it for future upgrades.

Aesen 116H vessel. Lehmann Marine’s CUBE battery system debuts in China aboard hybrid crew boat  

German battery maker’s first Chinese installation targets fuel savings on a Cheoy Lee-built vessel for a Singapore operator.

Person signing a document. Iino Lines secures transition loan from Mizuho Bank for LPG dual-fuel VLGC  

Japanese shipowner finances the acquisition of Lumi Aurora through a green transition finance framework aligned with ICMA guidelines.

ABS, HD KSOE and Siemens MoU signing. ABS, HD KSOE and Siemens partner on digital twin technology for ammonia-fuelled ship safety  

Three firms will combine CFD analysis and digital twin technology to assess ammonia leak scenarios in vessel design.

American Bureau of Shipping (ABS) logo. Nuclear-powered LNG carriers cost more upfront but cut lifetime fuel bills, ABS-backed study finds  

Joint study with Blossom Energy examines the economics of a 174,000-cbm LNG carrier powered by a small reactor.

Christos Doulaveris, Flex Commodities. Flex Commodities appoints Christos Doulaveris as general manager for Greece  

Bunker trader strengthens its Greek operations with a new leadership appointment.

Chang Ping Yuan vessel. China delivers first domestically built VLGC under Chinese flag  

Cosco Shipping’s new 88,000-cbm gas carrier features an LPG dual-fuel main engine.

IMO, GreenVoyage2050 and Republic of Türkiye MoTI logos. Electric and hybrid ferries could cut Sea of Marmara emissions by 63%, IMO study finds  

A GreenVoyage2050 study finds that electrification could slash emissions, avoid €492 million in damage costs and support jobs.


↑  Back to Top